Who Is the Best Pitcher in the MLB? The Dominance, Stats & Future of Baseball’s Elite Arms

Published

Baseball’s most pressing question isn’t whether pitching matters—it’s who matters most. In an era where velocity, command, and secondary pitches redefine dominance, the title of who is the best pitcher in the MLB shifts with each dominant season. The 2024 campaign has already delivered candidates who blur the line between legend and mortal: a 100-mph fastball here, a 3.00 ERA there, and a Cy Young race that feels like a coronation. But dominance isn’t just about numbers; it’s about how those numbers are achieved. A pitcher can strike out 250 batters but fail under pressure. Another might post a 2.50 ERA while missing 30 starts. The distinction between greatness and immortality often hinges on intangibles—clutch performances, postseason success, and the ability to elevate an entire team.

The debate over who is the best pitcher in the MLB has always been a mix of cold stats and narrative. In 2023, Shohei Ohtani’s two-way dominance made him the default answer, but injuries and the two-way grind left a void. Now, the conversation centers on a new class of aces: Jacob deGrom’s resurgence, Max Scherzer’s longevity, and the emergence of young guns like Dylan Lee. Each brings a unique skill set—deGrom’s pinpoint control, Scherzer’s power arsenal, Lee’s electric fastball—but none have yet matched the total package that defines generational pitchers. The question isn’t just about who’s leading the standings; it’s about who deserves to be remembered when the history books are written.

The search for the best pitcher in MLB history often begins with the Cy Young Award, baseball’s most prestigious individual honor. But the award’s flaws—its regional bias, lack of postseason consideration, and occasional snubs—mean the title is always up for debate. Take 2022: Gerrit Cole won the award despite a 3.08 ERA, while Justin Verlander (3.53 ERA, 239 Ks) finished second. Meanwhile, pitchers like Clayton Kershaw, who never won a Cy Young after three AL MVP seasons, remain untouchable in fan polls. The gap between statistical dominance and perceived greatness is where the conversation gets messy. Who is the best pitcher in the MLB today? The answer depends on whether you value peak performance, consistency, or legacy.

who is the best pitcher in the mlb

The Complete Overview of Who Is the Best Pitcher in the MLB

The modern era of MLB pitching is defined by specialization—pitchers who master one pitch (like Gerrit Cole’s slider) or dominate with sheer velocity (like Aaron Nola’s 100-mph heater). But the best pitchers in the game don’t just rely on one weapon; they adapt. Jacob deGrom’s return to the Mets in 2024 has reignited the debate over who is the best pitcher in the MLB, as his 98-mph fastball and 95-mph slider have already silenced doubters. Meanwhile, Max Scherzer, now with the Rangers, continues to defy age with a cutter that induces weak contact and a fastball that still sits at 95 mph. The difference between these two? DeGrom’s command is surgical, while Scherzer’s arsenal is built for chaos. Both approaches work—but which one defines greatness?

The answer isn’t binary. The best pitcher in MLB history, like the best pitcher in 2024, is often the one who elevates the game around them. Consider the 2023 World Series: Corey Kluber’s 1.69 ERA in the postseason didn’t win him a Cy Young, but his ability to shut down the Astros’ lineup in Game 4 made him a hero. Similarly, Dylan Lee’s 2023 season (2.93 ERA, 10.0 K/9) proved that even without a 3.00 ERA, a pitcher can be the reason a team wins. The modern game rewards pitchers who can pitch deep into games, protect leads, and generate weak contact. But the title of who is the best pitcher in the MLB still belongs to those who do it consistently—not just in one season, but over a career.

Historical Background and Evolution

The evolution of who is the best pitcher in the MLB mirrors the sport’s own transformation. In the 1920s, Walter Johnson’s 76 wins in 1913 and 1914 made him the undisputed ace, but his 95-mph fastball was a rarity. By the 1990s, velocity had become a arms race, with pitchers like Randy Johnson (102 mph) and Pedro Martinez (98 mph) redefining dominance. The 2000s brought the rise of the "three-pitch" pitcher—Kershaw’s curveball, Verlander’s cutter, and Cole’s slider—proving that command and movement mattered more than raw heat. Today, the debate over the best pitcher in MLB is less about who can throw the hardest fastball and more about who can sequence their pitches to generate the most swings-and-misses.

The Cy Young Award, introduced in 1956, became the de facto standard for measuring greatness. But the award’s criteria—ERA, WHIP, wins, strikeouts—don’t always capture a pitcher’s true impact. For example, Clayton Kershaw’s 2014 season (1.77 ERA, 229 Ks) was historically dominant, yet he didn’t win the award (Verlander did). Meanwhile, pitchers like Zack Greinke, who never won a Cy Young despite a 2.20 ERA in 2015, remain underrated. The modern game also values durability—pitchers who avoid the disabled list (DL) and accumulate 200+ innings. Scherzer’s ability to stay healthy into his 40s and deGrom’s 2023 return after Tommy John surgery highlight how resilience factors into the debate over who is the best pitcher in the MLB.

Core Mechanisms: How It Works

The mechanics behind who is the best pitcher in the MLB aren’t just about throwing hard—they’re about deception. A 95-mph fastball from Scherzer looks different than a 98-mph fastball from deGrom because of spin rate and release point. DeGrom’s fastball sits at 97-98 mph but has a spin rate of 2,600 RPM, making it tunnel harder than a typical 100-mph heater. Meanwhile, Scherzer’s cutter (92-94 mph) has a spin rate of 2,400 RPM but drops 12 inches—enough to turn a line drive into a groundout. The best pitchers in MLB history—from Sandy Koufax to Justin Verlander—understand that movement matters more than velocity alone.

Table of Contents

Command is the other half of the equation. A pitcher can have the best stuff in the world, but if they can’t locate their pitches, they’ll never be considered the best pitcher in the MLB. DeGrom’s career 2.90 ERA despite averaging 97.5 mph on his fastball proves this. His ability to paint the corners with every pitch—whether it’s a 95-mph slider or a changeup that sits at 84 mph—makes him untouchable. Meanwhile, young pitchers like Dylan Lee (99.5 mph fastball) are learning that control is the difference between being a star and a one-hit wonder. The best pitchers don’t just throw hard; they dictate the at-bat.

Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

The best pitcher in MLB isn’t just a stat line—he’s the foundation of a championship team. Teams with elite starting rotations (like the 2023 Astros or the 2022 Braves) win because their aces set the tone. A pitcher like Gerrit Cole doesn’t just lower the team’s ERA; he changes the culture. When Cole was traded to the Astros in 2020, Houston’s rotation went from solid to dominant, and they won the World Series. Similarly, the Mets’ 2024 push for a playoff spot hinges on deGrom’s ability to carry the staff. The ripple effect of having the best pitcher in the MLB extends beyond the mound—it boosts bullpen confidence, inspires hitters, and gives managers flexibility.

The economic impact is just as significant. A top-tier pitcher like Scherzer or deGrom isn’t just a player; he’s an asset. Scherzer’s 2023 contract with the Rangers was worth $130 million over three years—a testament to his value. Meanwhile, deGrom’s return to the Mets made them a World Series contender overnight, driving ticket sales and merchandise revenue. The best pitchers in MLB history—from Babe Ruth to Roger Clemens—have always been the face of their franchises. Their dominance translates into revenue, and their injuries can cripple a team’s value. For teams, the question isn’t who is the best pitcher in the MLB—it’s how do we get one?

"Pitching stops runs better than fielding stops hits." — Casey Stengel

Major Advantages

  • Postseason Success: The best pitchers in MLB history (like Cole or Kershaw) thrive in October. Cole’s 2.51 ERA in the postseason is the lowest among modern aces, while Kershaw’s 2014 World Series performance (1.88 ERA) cemented his legacy.
  • Durability: Scherzer’s ability to pitch deep into games (6+ innings per start) and avoid the DL makes him a rare commodity. In 2023, he averaged 6.5 innings per start at age 40.
  • Clutch Performances: A pitcher like deGrom doesn’t just win games—he controls them. His 2023 no-hitter against the Braves was the 30th in MLB history, a move that redefined his career.
  • Arsenal Depth: The best pitchers in the MLB (like Verlander or Cole) don’t rely on one pitch. Verlander’s cutter and changeup are just as feared as his fastball, making them unpredictable.
  • Leadership: Pitchers like Cole and Scherzer set the tone for their teams. Their work ethic and professionalism elevate the entire rotation.

who is the best pitcher in the mlb - Ilustrasi 2

Comparative Analysis

Pitcher Key Strengths
Jacob deGrom (2024) 98-mph fastball, 95-mph slider, 2.80 career ERA, 2023 no-hitter
Max Scherzer (2024) 95-mph fastball, 92-mph cutter, 3.00 career ERA, 2023 Cy Young (3rd)
Gerrit Cole (2023) 99-mph fastball, 90-mph slider, 2.90 career ERA, 2023 AL Cy Young
Dylan Lee (2023) 99.5-mph fastball, 96-mph slider, 2.93 ERA, 2023 NL Rookie of the Year
The future of who is the best pitcher in the MLB will be shaped by technology and analytics. Pitch-tracking data (like Statcast’s spin rate and exit velocity metrics) is already changing how pitchers train. Young arms like Lee and Kyle Bradish are using Rapsodo and TrackMan to refine their mechanics, leading to more efficient delivery and fewer injuries. Meanwhile, teams are investing in pitch design—like the Astros’ use of data to optimize Cole’s slider or the Braves’ focus on weak contact rates. The next generation of aces won’t just throw hard; they’ll optimize every pitch.

Another trend is the rise of the two-way pitcher. Ohtani’s dominance proved that a player with a 100-mph fastball and 100-mph swing can be the best in the game. While no one has replicated his exact profile, the MLB is likely to see more hybrid players—either elite pitchers with Gold Glove potential or power hitters with ace-level stuff. The debate over the best pitcher in MLB history may soon include names like Ohtani or even Shohei’s successor. As the game evolves, the title won’t just go to the hardest thrower or the lowest ERA pitcher—it’ll go to the most versatile arm.

who is the best pitcher in the mlb - Ilustrasi 3

Conclusion

The question of who is the best pitcher in the MLB in 2024 remains unresolved—and that’s the point. Baseball’s greatest pitchers aren’t defined by a single season; they’re defined by how they make the game better. DeGrom’s return has reignited the debate, Scherzer’s longevity has redefined aging, and Lee’s rise proves that raw talent can translate into dominance. But the true measure of greatness isn’t just stats; it’s legacy. Koufax, Clemens, and Kershaw didn’t just win awards—they changed how the game was played. The best pitcher in MLB history isn’t the one with the best numbers today; it’s the one who leaves an indelible mark on the sport.

For now, the title is up for grabs. Scherzer’s 2024 season could push him into the conversation for greatest pitcher ever. DeGrom’s health and performance will determine if he’s a one-season wonder or a generational ace. And young pitchers like Lee and Bradish are already setting the bar for the next era. The answer to who is the best pitcher in the MLB isn’t just about today—it’s about who will still be discussed in 20 years.

Comprehensive FAQs

Q: Who is currently considered the best pitcher in the MLB in 2024?

A: As of mid-2024, Jacob deGrom is the leading candidate due to his 2.80 ERA, 98-mph fastball, and 2023 no-hitter. However, Max Scherzer (3.00 ERA, 2023 Cy Young) and Gerrit Cole (2.90 career ERA) remain strong contenders.

Q: Has any pitcher ever won a Cy Young Award unanimously?

A: No. The closest was Randy Johnson in 2002 (32 of 32 first-place votes), but unanimous wins are rare. Most Cy Young winners face competition from peers with similar stats.

Q: What makes a pitcher "elite" beyond just strikeouts or ERA?

A: Elite pitchers combine dominance (high K/9, low BB/9), durability (low DL trips), and postseason success. Command, pitch movement, and the ability to elevate a team’s performance are also key.

Q: Can a pitcher still be considered the best in the MLB after age 40?

A: Yes—Max Scherzer (40 in 2024) and CC Sabathia (39 in 2019) have proven it. However, velocity and durability often decline, so longevity becomes the defining factor.

Q: Who holds the record for the most Cy Young Awards?

A: Randy Johnson and Roger Clemens share the record with 7 Cy Young Awards (5 AL, 2 NL for Clemens; 5 NL, 2 AL for Johnson).

Q: How does Statcast data change the debate over who is the best pitcher in the MLB?

A: Statcast’s spin rate, exit velocity, and pitch movement metrics provide deeper insights than traditional stats. For example, deGrom’s 2,600 RPM fastball is more effective than a 100-mph heater with less spin.

Q: What’s the difference between a "dominant" pitcher and a "great" pitcher?

A: Dominant pitchers (like Cole in 2023) have elite numbers in a single season. Great pitchers (like Kershaw or Clemens) sustain dominance over multiple years and often win championships.

Q: Can a pitcher with a high ERA still be considered the best in the MLB?

A: Rarely. While ERA is important, context matters—injuries, bullpen support, and era difficulty play a role. For example, Justin Verlander’s 3.53 ERA in 2022 was still elite due to his K/9 and weak contact rates.

Q: Who is the most underrated pitcher in MLB history?

A: Greg Maddux is often cited as the most underrated due to his 3.16 career ERA, 355 wins, and 18 Gold Gloves—all while being overshadowed by strikeout pitchers like Clemens.

Leave a Comment

Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of Viralcontentbee.